Jason Duggar’s Lawsuit over Home Repairs Dismissed.
March 8, 2025 — A lawsuit against former reality TV star Jason Duggar, filed over home repairs in Benton County, Arkansas, has been dismissed with prejudice, meaning it cannot be reopened. This ruling comes six months after Duggar was accused of fraud and other legal violations.
According to court documents, the lawsuit was dismissed on March 6, 2025, after the plaintiff, Mark Thompson, requested its dismissal. Circuit Judge Christine Horwart approved the motion the same day. The motion did not provide a specific reason for the dismissal but stated that each party would bear their own fees and costs.
Background: The Home Repair Dispute
The lawsuit, originally filed in September 2024, accused Duggar of fraud, breach of contract, breach of warranties, and negligence. Thompson, the plaintiff, claimed that Duggar, the contractor for a home he purchased, failed to complete necessary repairs and misrepresented himself as a licensed contractor.
According to court documents, Thompson bought a three-bedroom house from Madison Holding, LLC, in September 2023 for $350,000. Duggar was contracted to complete various repairs, including work on the roof, drywall, and crown molding. However, Thompson alleged that Duggar never provided proof of a valid contractor’s license, and that some repairs were never completed by the agreed deadline.
Accusations of Fraud and Misrepresentation
The court papers revealed that Duggar, who was listed as the contractor for the project, was accused of misrepresenting himself as licensed. Specifically, the documents stated that Duggar “cannot be found on the Arkansas Contractors Licensing Board” and that his contractor’s license “does not appear to be valid.”
Thompson claimed that Duggar not only failed to perform the required repairs but also proposed paying for the repairs himself and having Thompson sign a contract absolving him of any further responsibility for the work.
The Legal Drama Unfolds
Thompson’s lawyer, Andrew Myers, expressed frustration over the long process, stating, “We’ve been trying to get this resolved going on a year now, and it’s been like pulling teeth. Usually, it’s pretty easy to fix all of this.”
Further complicating the situation, Kristyn Hutson, the coordinator for the Arkansas Contractors Licensing Board, confirmed that Duggar’s company, Build Masters Construction, failed to renew its license in September 2023 due to missing financial documents. Hutson explained that “it’s against the law to build a house without a license” unless the builder is the one occupying the home.
Duggar’s Response to Allegations
In October 2024, the company filed a motion denying the allegations, asserting that they had fully complied with the terms of the contract and requested that the lawsuit be dismissed.
Duggar himself also sought to be removed from the lawsuit, claiming that Thompson had failed to present factual evidence linking him to the allegations. Duggar’s motion for dismissal cited “failure to plead facts or attach a signed writing” under which Duggar could be held responsible.
Dismissal With Prejudice: What It Means
The dismissal of the case “with prejudice” means that the lawsuit is permanently closed, and Thompson cannot refile the case on the same claims. The motion did not explain why Thompson chose to drop the case, but both parties were ordered to cover their own legal costs.
Impact of the Lawsuit’s Dismissal
Although the lawsuit has been dismissed, the controversy surrounding Duggar’s legal issues remains. Duggar’s company’s failure to maintain proper licensing and the allegations of fraud could have lasting consequences for his reputation and future business endeavors. Furthermore, the case highlights the importance of contractors following legal guidelines and the potential risks of working without a valid license.
What’s Next for Jason Duggar?
Jason Duggar, 24, rose to fame as part of the Duggar family on the reality TV show 19 Kids and Counting. Since the legal troubles began, he has remained out of the public eye, except for his social media posts and business endeavors. As of now, no further legal actions have been indicated following the dismissal of this case.
Thompson’s lawyer has not made any additional public statements since the dismissal, and there is no indication if Thompson plans to pursue other legal avenues against Duggar or Madison Holding.
Jason Duggar’s lawsuit over home repairs has come to a close with the dismissal of the case on March 6, 2025. Despite the legal battle, Duggar and Madison Holding LLC denied the accusations of fraud, and the case has now been closed permanently. With both parties left to bear their own costs, it’s unclear whether any further legal action will be taken.