Creating and updating governance documents, such as operating, partnership, and shareholder agreements, is vital for a founder-owned law firm’s long-term success. These documents define the firm’s structure, decision-making processes, and transition protocols. This guide outlines key areas to address, real-world examples, and actionable steps to help firms navigate generational transitions with confidence.
Mandatory Retirement Age |
Including provisions for retirement age within your governing documents can help facilitate orderly transitions and prevent potential conflicts. While mandatory retirement ages may not be suitable for all first-generation firms, having a structured retirement planning process is crucial.
Action Steps:
- Require partners to declare retirement intentions upon reaching a set age (e.g., 60)
- Create a flexible “retirement window” to allow phased planning.
Example:
A law firm implemented a policy requiring partners to declare their retirement timeline upon reaching 60. A founding partner, unsure of exactly when and how to retire, created a retirement window with specific action steps keyed to the attainment of certain milestones over a 7-year period.
Return of Capital and Net Asset Interests |
Retiring partners are typically owed a return of fixed capital and undistributed earnings. A clearly defined payout schedule protects the firm’s financial health during transitions.
Action Steps:
-
Define how and when capital will be returned to retiring partners.
-
Develop a recapitalization plan for new and remaining equity owners.
-
Establish a valuation process for Accounts Receivable (AR) and Work in Progress (WIP) interests.
-
Limit ownership in billing assets for future equity owners.
- Create a payout schedule for AR and WIP, net of any related debt.
Example:
A mid-sized law firm faced financial difficulties due to ambiguous capital return policies and the challenge of replacing the capital owed to a retiring equity owner by the remaining equity owners. By updating its agreement with an extended payout schedule, the firm maintained financial stability while honoring its commitments.
. Post-Retirement Liability Obligations |
Firms must address post-retirement liabilities, such as lease and debt guarantees, which are critical to protect both retiring partners and the firm. Clear policies governing these obligations should be included in the governance documents.
Action Steps:
- Review and revise lease and debt guarantee policies.
- Clearly define the conditions for releasing continuing guarantees.
-
Clearly define when obligations are released.
-
Establish contingency plans for unresolved liabilities.
Example:
A small law firm with younger, less established equity owners wanted to release the retiring founding equity owner from the line of credit. The firm’s bank was initially uncomfortable with a complete release. The retiring equity owner agreed to back the line of credit through the buyout period.
Post-Retirement Compensation |
Providing post-retirement compensation options ensures fairness and clarity. This may include stipends or a share of the generated fees.
Action Steps:
- Establish clear post-retirement compensation policies.
- Limit the payment period to maintain financial balance.
- Address post-retirement competition and its impact on retirement compensation.
Example:
A law firm offered a two-year stipend to retiring partners, conditional on full retirement. If they started a private practice or joined another firm post-retirement, the firm could void future payments.
Transfer of Equity Interests & Capital Requirements |
An orderly transfer of equity interests ensures the firm’s longevity and growth. Clear policies for new and lateral partner equity are essential.
Action Steps:
- Set equity contribution standards for new and lateral partners.
- Use a common formula (e.g., ownership percentage or compensation basis) to equalize capital contributions.
- Implement a vesting or buy-in process to ensure commitment.
Example:
A law firm needed a process to admit new equity owners. Without prior experience, they found it challenging to determine the timing and basis for ownership transfers. They adopted a three-year vesting approach and updated their governance documents with new owner admission policies. This provided clarity and eased the onboarding of future partners.
Firm Valuation Provisions |
Valuing the firm is one of the most challenging yet vital elements of transition planning. Most firms begin with book value (e.g., AR and WIP), though this rarely reflects intangible assets such as the firm’s reputation,, systems and processes, people, brand equity and even the cost of starting a new firm. Difficult as it is, law firms should address this issue well in advance of founder retirements.
Action Steps:
- Define a valuation approach for firm assets.
- Define how this value is allocated to equity interests.
Example:
A group of founding equity owners nearing retirement decided to value the firm for sale to senior attorneys. Despite some contentious discussions, they agreed to value the firm based on book value plus a percentage of collected income post-retirement. Starting the process 5 years before any retirements allowed new equity owners time to adjust and plan.
| Common Pitfalls to Avoid |
- No required planning or declaration age for retirement
- Unclear capital return and payout policies.
- Inadequate management of post-retirement liabilities.
- Undefined post-retirement compensation plans.
- Lack of clear equity transfer procedures.
- Inaccurate valuation of firm assets.
Conclusion
Modernizing governing documents is a foundational step for law firms preparing for generational transitions. By addressing key areas such as retirement provisions, capital management, equity transfers, compensation, and firm valuation, firms establish a solid foundation for future growth and adaptability.